Karen McMahon Wins Re-Election in the 146th District

Assemblywoman Karen M. McMahon
Photo: New York State Assembly
Assemblywoman Karen M. McMahon won another term in the 146th Assembly District on Nov. 3, beating Republican Terence G. McGuire 30,703 to 18,872 in Erie County’s unofficial count. McMahon, a Democrat, represents the Amherst-based district and won by 11,831 votes.
McMahon ran only on the Democratic line, while McGuire ran on the Republican and Conservative lines. The 146th drew more ballots than any other contested Assembly race in Erie County this year, 50,651 by PagPol’s count of votes, write-ins and blank ballots.
Quick Facts
Office
State Assembly, 146th District
Winner
Karen M. McMahon (Democratic)
Runner-up
Terence G. McGuire (Republican, Conservative)
Result
30,703 to 18,872 (61.9% to 38.1%)
Margin
11,831 votes, 23.9 points
Status
Unofficial; includes absentee ballots received through Nov. 10
Takes office
Jan. 1, 2027

THE RESULTS

McMahon won 61.9 percent of the votes cast for candidates, a margin of 23.9 points. The count includes absentee ballots received through Nov. 10, according to the Board of Elections’ unofficial results. Affidavit and late military ballots may still be added before the county certifies the results.

Assembly 146: how Erie County voted

AD-146 (Erie portion, 63 EDs). Erie County votes only; district-wide results are reported separately. Bars split by party line. Unofficial.

Karen M. McMahonDemocratic
30,703 (61.9%)
Terence G. McGuireRepublican, Conservative
18,872 (38.1%)
Write-ins
40
No vote in this race
1,036
DemocraticRepublicanConservativeWrite-ins and blanks
Source: Erie County Board of Elections, unofficial results, 652 of 652 precincts, updated Nov. 10, 2026
Karen M. McMahon beat Terence G. McGuire, 30,703 to 18,872. Write-ins: 40. No vote in this race: 1,036 (PagPol calculation).
Amherst cast 50,306 votes for governor this year, second only to the city of Buffalo among Erie County’s cities and towns. Voters there also approved a town proposition, 29,261 to 15,128, with 65.9 percent voting yes, according to the unofficial results.

HOW THE VOTE BROKE DOWN

McMahon’s 30,703 votes all came on the Democratic line. McGuire drew 15,309 votes on the Republican line and 3,563 on the Conservative line. McMahon’s single-line total was about double McGuire’s Republican line and outpolled his two-line total by 11,831 votes.
Voters cast 40 write-ins, and 1,036 ballots left the race blank, by PagPol’s calculation, or 2.0 percent. That was one of the lowest blank rates among Erie County’s contested Assembly races, where the rate ranged from 1.8 percent in the 143rd to 7.4 percent in the 140th, excluding the tiny Erie portion of the 150th.
Autumn trees along Mary Talbert Way on the University at Buffalo North Campus in Amherst
Autumn trees along Mary Talbert Way on the University at Buffalo North Campus in Amherst. (Photo: Andre Carrotflower, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons)

HOW IT COMPARES

McMahon’s 23.9-point margin was in the middle of Erie County’s 14 contested state and federal races. The chart below ranks each race by the gap between the top two candidates in the county’s vote, using the share of votes cast for candidates.

Erie County's margin in each contested state and federal race

Points between the top two candidates in Erie County's vote only, share of votes cast for candidates. Unofficial.

Assembly 143571 votes
1.2 pts
Assembly 1422,987 votes
6.4 pts
Governor39,303 votes
11.3 pts
Attorney general46,156 votes
13.3 pts
NY-2319,087 votes
14.7 pts
Assembly 1451,577 votes
15.7 pts
Assembly 1445,068 votes
18.3 pts
Comptroller77,861 votes
22.6 pts
Assembly 146 (this race)11,831 votes
23.9 pts
Assembly 14910,401 votes
24.7 pts
NY-2678,168 votes
36.1 pts
Senate 6333,792 votes
40.7 pts
Assembly 15096 votes
45.7 pts
Assembly 14021,535 votes
56.2 pts
This raceOther contested races
Source: Erie County Board of Elections, unofficial results, 652 of 652 election districts, updated Nov. 10, 2026
Margins are from the county’s unofficial count, which includes absentee ballots received through Nov. 10, and can shift slightly before certification.
Amherst also votes in the 26th Congressional District, where Rep. Tim Kennedy, a Democrat, carried Erie County’s share by 36.1 points on the same ballots. Republican Edward A. Rath III, a lifelong Amherst resident, won the open Legislature seat in District 6, which includes part of Amherst.

WHAT HAPPENS NEXT

McMahon’s new two-year term begins Jan. 1, 2027. All 150 Assembly seats were on the ballot this year. The county Board of Elections will add any remaining affidavit and military ballots during its canvass, then certify the results later in November.
For results in every Erie County race, plus profiles of the officials who represent each town and city, visit PagPol’s Erie County page or subscribe to the Erie County newsletter. PagPol will update these numbers when the Board of Elections adds the last affidavit and military ballots and certifies the count.
Share the Post:

Join the Erie Newsletter

Related Posts

Scroll to Top