John Gilmour Wins Re-Election in Legislature District 9

Erie County Legislator John J. Gilmour
Photo: Erie County Legislature
Legislator John J. Gilmour, a Democrat, won another two-year term in Erie County Legislature District 9 on Nov. 3, beating Republican David M. Denz 19,248 to 11,278 in the county’s unofficial count. His 26.1-point margin was the widest of the Legislature’s five contested races this year.
Gilmour is an attorney and a partner at Gilmour & Killelea on Main Street in the village of Hamburg, according to his county biography, after starting a private practice in Lackawanna. He ran on both the Democratic and Conservative lines this fall, while Denz appeared only on the Republican line.
Quick Facts
Office
Erie County Legislature, District 9
Winner
John J. Gilmour (Democratic, Conservative)
Runner-up
David M. Denz (Republican)
Result
19,248 to 11,278 (63.1% to 36.9%)
Margin
7,970 votes, 26.1 points
Status
Unofficial; includes absentee ballots received through Nov. 10
Term
Two years, starting Jan. 1, 2027

THE RESULTS

Gilmour won 63.1 percent of the votes cast for candidates, a margin of 7,970 votes. The count includes absentee ballots received through Nov. 10, according to the Board of Elections’ unofficial results. District 9 cast 32,039 ballots in the race, by PagPol’s count of votes, write-ins and blank ballots.

Erie County Legislature, District 9

Bars split by party line. Unofficial.

John J. Gilmour (winner)Democratic, Conservative
19,248 (63.1%)
David M. DenzRepublican
11,278 (36.9%)
Write-ins
52
No vote in this race
1,461
DemocraticRepublicanConservativeWrite-ins and blanks
Source: Erie County Board of Elections, unofficial results, 652 of 652 precincts, updated Nov. 10, 2026
John J. Gilmour beat David M. Denz, 19,248 to 11,278. Write-ins: 52. No vote in this race: 1,461 (PagPol calculation).
District 9 was one of five contested Legislature races this year. Six other legislators ran unopposed, and Democrats kept their 7 to 4 majority. The district covers South Buffalo, Lackawanna, Hamburg and Blasdell, according to Gilmour’s county biography, and is one of the seven seats Democrats hold.

HOW THE VOTE BROKE DOWN

Gilmour’s Democratic line carried 16,785 votes and the Conservative line added 2,463. Denz drew all 11,278 of his votes on the Republican line. Gilmour’s Democratic line alone outpolled Denz by 5,507 votes, so he would have won the seat even without the Conservative line’s support.
Voters cast 52 write-ins, and 1,461 District 9 ballots left the race blank, by PagPol’s calculation. That is 4.6 percent of the ballots cast in the race, the highest blank rate among the five contested Legislature districts, where the rate otherwise ranged from 2.0 to 2.9 percent.
Map of Erie County Legislature District 9
District 9, highlighted, among the 11 Erie County Legislature districts. (Map: Erie County Legislature)

HOW IT COMPARES

Gilmour’s 26.1-point margin edged out Legislator Jeanne M. Vinal’s 26.0 points in District 5 for the widest among Erie County’s contested local races. The chart below ranks every contested local race on the county’s ballot by the gap between the winner and the runner-up, using the share of votes cast for candidates.

Winning margin in Erie County's contested local races

Points between the last winner and the first loser, share of votes cast for candidates. Supreme Court margin is Erie County's vote only. Unofficial.

Supreme Court, 8th District (county vote)25,399 votes
2.0 pts
County clerk13,927 votes
4.0 pts
Aurora supervisor433 votes
6.1 pts
West Seneca town council1,302 votes
6.7 pts
Cheektowaga town council2,799 votes
9.1 pts
Legislature District 63,747 votes
9.8 pts
Aurora town council746 votes
10.2 pts
Legislature District 116,320 votes
16.0 pts
Legislature District 87,551 votes
19.9 pts
Brant town council178 votes
22.7 pts
Collins town justice395 votes
23.1 pts
Legislature District 58,302 votes
26.0 pts
Legislature District 9 (this race)7,970 votes
26.1 pts
This raceOther contested races
Source: Erie County Board of Elections, unofficial results, 652 of 652 election districts, updated Nov. 10, 2026
Margins are from the county’s unofficial count, which includes absentee ballots received through Nov. 10, and can shift slightly before certification.
Both of the Legislature’s lopsided contested races went to Democratic incumbents. On the same ballots, Erie County voters returned Rep. Tim Kennedy to Congress in the 26th District, while southern towns in the 23rd District backed Rep. Nicholas A. Langworthy, a Republican, in the county’s count.

WHAT HAPPENS NEXT

Gilmour’s new term begins Jan. 1, 2027. The Legislature will choose its leadership at its first meeting of the year, with Democrats holding seven of the 11 seats. The Board of Elections will add any remaining affidavit and military ballots during its canvass, then certify the results later in November.
For results in every Erie County race, plus profiles of the officials who represent each town and city, visit PagPol’s Erie County page or subscribe to the Erie County newsletter. PagPol will update these numbers when the Board of Elections adds the last affidavit and military ballots and certifies the count.
Share the Post:

Join the Erie Newsletter

Related Posts

Scroll to Top