Photo: Warren LeMay from Chicago, IL, United States, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Democrat Joseph Zavaglia carried Onondaga County in the race for one seat on the State Supreme Court’s 5th Judicial District on Nov. 3, beating Republican Michael J. Manfredi by 101,121 votes to 71,119 in the county’s election night count. But Onondaga is one of six counties in the district.
District-wide, unofficial tallies compiled from county results showed Manfredi ahead, 52.4 percent to 47.6 percent, with about 99 percent of the vote counted, and no winner had been declared. Manfredi carried Oneida County, 45,119 to 30,290, offsetting much of Zavaglia’s 30,002-vote lead in Onondaga County.
Quick Facts
Office
State Supreme Court, 5th Judicial District (one seat)
Onondaga County result
Joseph Zavaglia (Democratic, Working Families) 101,121; Michael J. Manfredi (Republican, Conservative) 71,119
Onondaga County margin
30,002 votes for Zavaglia
District-wide
Manfredi led 52.4% to 47.6% with about 99% counted, unofficial; no winner declared
District
Onondaga, Oneida, Herkimer, Jefferson, Lewis and Oswego counties
Status
Unofficial election night count, 449 of 449 precincts
THE ONONDAGA COUNTY VOTE
Zavaglia won 58.7 percent of Onondaga County’s votes cast for candidates to Manfredi’s 41.3 percent, a 30,002-vote margin across all 449 precincts. Absentee ballots that arrived after Election Day and affidavit ballots were counted later in each of the district’s six counties and are not in these figures.
State Supreme Court, 5th District: how Onondaga County voted
5th Judicial District (Onondaga portion). Onondaga County votes only; district-wide results are reported separately. Bars split by party line. Unofficial.
Joseph ZavagliaDemocratic, Working Families
101,121 (58.7%)
Michael J. ManfrediRepublican, Conservative
71,119 (41.3%)
Write-ins
70
No vote in this race
3,551
DemocraticWorking FamiliesRepublicanConservativeWrite-ins and blanks
Source: Onondaga County Board of Elections, unofficial election night results, 449 of 449 precincts, as of Nov. 4, 2026
Joseph Zavaglia’s and Michael J. Manfredi’s votes in Onondaga County only, by party line, with write-ins and blank ballots. District-wide results are reported separately.
Zavaglia drew 92,210 on the Democratic line and 8,911 on the Working Families line. Manfredi drew 61,057 on the Republican line and 10,062 on the Conservative line. Write-in votes totaled 70, and 3,551 ballots recorded no vote in the race, a PagPol calculation, since the county does not report blank ballots.
HOW THE VOTE BROKE DOWN
The 5th Judicial District covers Onondaga, Oneida, Herkimer, Jefferson, Lewis and Oswego counties. Supreme Court justices are elected district-wide to 14-year terms and hear the state’s major civil cases, including divorces, large lawsuits and challenges to government actions, along with some felony criminal cases.
The Onondaga County vote mirrored the County Court race on the same ballot, where Democrat Jeffrey G. Leibo unseated Judge Matthew J. Doran by 16,932 votes. Zavaglia ran about 6,600 votes ahead of Leibo in the county, and Manfredi ran about 6,400 votes behind Doran.
The Onondaga County Courthouse at Montgomery and Jefferson streets (Photo: Warren LeMay from Chicago, IL, United States, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons)
HOW IT COMPARES
Zavaglia’s 17.4-point margin in Onondaga County ranked second-closest among the seven races decided by every voter in the county, behind only the County Court race. It was close to Gov. Kathy Hochul’s 19.9-point margin in the county and narrower than Sheriff Toby Shelley’s 26.7 points.
Winning margin in each race on every Onondaga County ballot
Points between the top two candidates countywide. State and federal races are Onondaga County's vote only. Election night count, unofficial.
County Court judge16,932 votes
9.8 pts
Supreme Court, 5th District (county vote) (this race)30,002 votes
17.4 pts
Governor (county vote)34,620 votes
19.9 pts
Attorney General (county vote)36,282 votes
20.9 pts
NY-22 (county vote)46,308 votes
26.6 pts
Sheriff46,026 votes
26.7 pts
Comptroller (county vote)51,567 votes
29.8 pts
This raceOther races
Source: Onondaga County Board of Elections, unofficial election night results, 449 of 449 precincts, as of Nov. 4, 2026
Margins come from the county’s election night count. Absentee ballots that arrived after Election Day and affidavit ballots were counted later and can shift them slightly before certification.
Onondaga County’s large Democratic margins in countywide races this year did not carry over to Oneida County, the district’s other large county, where Manfredi won by 14,829 votes. Rep. John Mannion, a Democrat, carried Onondaga County by 26.6 points in the 22nd Congressional District on the same ballot.
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT
Each of the six counties will certify its own results, and the state Board of Elections will then certify the district-wide winner, which it must do by mid-December. PagPol will update this page if the district-wide count changes the leader. Onondaga County expects to certify its results in late November.
For results in every Onondaga County race, plus profiles of the officials who represent each city, town and village, visit PagPol’s Onondaga County page or subscribe to the Onondaga County newsletter. PagPol will update these numbers after the Board of Elections finishes counting late absentee and affidavit ballots and certifies the results.