Photo: MattCC716, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Onondaga County Sheriff Toby Shelley won a second term on Nov. 3, beating Republican RJ Lenhart by 109,194 votes to 63,168 in the county’s election night count. Shelley, a Democrat, took 63.4 percent of the votes cast for candidates, a margin of 46,026 votes across all 449 precincts.
Shelley ran on the Democratic line and a minor line listed as WTP, which drew 3,101 votes. Lenhart ran on the Republican and Conservative lines. Shelley first won the office in 2022, becoming the county’s first Democratic sheriff since 1978, and he thanked Lenhart for a “spirited campaign” after the results came in.
Quick Facts
Office
Onondaga County sheriff
Winner
Toby Shelley (Democratic, WTP)
Runner-up
RJ Lenhart (Republican, Conservative)
Result
109,194 to 63,168 (63.4% to 36.6%)
Margin
46,026 votes
Status
Unofficial election night count, 449 of 449 precincts
THE RESULTS
Shelley won 63.4 percent of the votes cast for candidates to 36.6 percent for Lenhart, a margin of 46,026 votes, in the Board of Elections’ unofficial results from all 449 precincts. Absentee ballots that arrived after Election Day and affidavit ballots were counted later and are not in these figures.
DemocraticRepublicanConservativeOther party linesWrite-ins and blanks
Source: Onondaga County Board of Elections, unofficial election night results, 449 of 449 precincts, as of Nov. 4, 2026
Toby Shelley’s votes on the Democratic and WTP lines against RJ Lenhart’s on the Republican and Conservative lines, with write-ins and blank ballots.
Shelley drew 106,093 on the Democratic line and 3,101 on the WTP line. Lenhart drew 54,346 on the Republican line and 8,822 on the Conservative line. Write-in votes totaled 153, and 3,346 ballots recorded no vote in the race, a PagPol calculation, since the county does not report blank ballots.
HOW THE VOTE BROKE DOWN
The sheriff’s office runs the county’s Justice Center jail, provides road patrols across the county and handles civil process such as serving court papers. Shelley’s second term begins in January 2027. County Executive Ryan McMahon, a Republican, appoints many county department heads, but the sheriff is elected separately.
Shelley’s Democratic line alone, with 106,093 votes, outpolled Lenhart’s two lines combined by nearly 43,000 votes. Lenhart’s 8,822 votes on the Conservative line were in line with what that party’s candidates for governor and comptroller drew in the county, 8,758 and 8,820 votes.
The Onondaga County Courthouse on Montgomery Street in downtown Syracuse (Photo: Warren LeMay from Chicago, IL, United States, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons)
HOW IT COMPARES
Shelley’s 26.7-point margin was the second-widest of the seven races decided by every voter in Onondaga County, wider than the County Court and State Supreme Court races and the county’s votes for governor and attorney general. Only Comptroller Thomas P. DiNapoli carried the county by a wider share.
Winning margin in each race on every Onondaga County ballot
Points between the top two candidates countywide. State and federal races are Onondaga County's vote only. Election night count, unofficial.
County Court judge16,932 votes
9.8 pts
Supreme Court, 5th District (county vote)30,002 votes
17.4 pts
Governor (county vote)34,620 votes
19.9 pts
Attorney General (county vote)36,282 votes
20.9 pts
NY-22 (county vote)46,308 votes
26.6 pts
Sheriff (this race)46,026 votes
26.7 pts
Comptroller (county vote)51,567 votes
29.8 pts
This raceOther races
Source: Onondaga County Board of Elections, unofficial election night results, 449 of 449 precincts, as of Nov. 4, 2026
Margins come from the county’s election night count. Absentee ballots that arrived after Election Day and affidavit ballots were counted later and can shift them slightly before certification.
Shelley ran well ahead of other Democrats on the countywide ballot. His 109,194 votes were nearly 5,000 more than Gov. Kathy Hochul’s 104,366 in the county, though fewer than DiNapoli’s 112,315 and Rep. John Mannion‘s 110,360 in the 22nd Congressional District.
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT
The Board of Elections is counting the last absentee and affidavit ballots before it certifies the results in late November. Shelley’s new four-year term begins on Jan. 1, 2027. With a margin of more than 46,000 votes, the remaining ballots will not change the outcome of the race.
For results in every Onondaga County race, plus profiles of the officials who represent each city, town and village, visit PagPol’s Onondaga County page or subscribe to the Onondaga County newsletter. PagPol will update these numbers after the Board of Elections finishes counting late absentee and affidavit ballots and certifies the results.