Photo: DanielPenfield, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Republican Michael A. Aregano unseated Cicero Town Supervisor Rob Santucci on Nov. 3, winning 6,857 votes to 6,560 in Onondaga County’s election night count. The 297-vote margin made Cicero one of the two closest supervisor races in the county, along with Pompey, where the incumbent survived by 75 votes.
Aregano ran on the Republican and Conservative lines and a third line listed as CIF, which drew no votes. Santucci, a Democrat, ran on the Democratic and Working Families lines. Santucci was listed as Cicero’s supervisor on the county’s roster of elected officials in April 2026, and he was one of two supervisors to lose on Nov. 3.
Quick Facts
Office
Cicero town supervisor
Winner
Michael A. Aregano (Republican, Conservative, CIF)
Runner-up
Rob Santucci (Democratic, Working Families)
Result
6,857 to 6,560 (51.1% to 48.9%)
Margin
297 votes
Status
Unofficial election night count, 449 of 449 precincts
THE RESULTS
Aregano won 51.1 percent of the votes cast for candidates to 48.9 percent for Santucci, a margin of 297 votes, in the Board of Elections’ unofficial results from all 449 precincts. Absentee ballots that arrived after Election Day and affidavit ballots were counted later and are not in these figures.
Michael A. Aregano ✓(winner)Republican, Conservative, CIF
6,857 (51.1%)
Rob SantucciDemocratic, Working Families
6,560 (48.9%)
Write-ins
21
No vote in this race
267
DemocraticWorking FamiliesRepublicanConservativeWrite-ins and blanks
Source: Onondaga County Board of Elections, unofficial election night results, 449 of 449 precincts, as of Nov. 4, 2026
Michael A. Aregano’s votes on the Republican, Conservative, CIF lines against Rob Santucci’s on the Democratic, Working Families lines, with write-ins and blank ballots.
Aregano drew 5,960 on the Republican line, 897 on the Conservative line and 0 on the CIF line. Santucci drew 6,079 on the Democratic line and 481 on the Working Families line. Write-in votes totaled 21, and 267 ballots recorded no vote in the race, a PagPol calculation, since the county does not report blank ballots.
HOW THE VOTE BROKE DOWN
Santucci’s Democratic line outpolled Aregano’s Republican line, 6,079 to 5,960. Aregano’s 897 Conservative votes outweighed Santucci’s 481 on the Working Families line, giving the challenger the edge. It was one of several Onondaga County races where the Conservative line provided a Republican’s winning margin.
Cicero’s other contested races also went Republican. Town Justice Douglas M. DeMarche Jr. beat Democrat Nate Riley by 659 votes, and Republicans Tracy M. Cosilmon, Christopher J. Woznica and Torrie L. Gavin ran unopposed for clerk, highway superintendent and receiver of taxes, each drawing more than 9,900 votes.
The waterfront in Brewerton during the 2025 Erie Canal bicentennial voyage (Photo: DanielPenfield, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons)
HOW IT COMPARES
Aregano’s 2.2-point margin was the second-closest of the 10 contested town supervisor races in Onondaga County, a hair behind Pompey, where Democratic Supervisor Diana Carpenter won by 75 votes. Republicans won three of the 10 contested supervisor races, in Cicero, Marcellus and the town of Onondaga.
Winning margin in each contested town supervisor race
Points between the winner and runner-up, share of votes cast for candidates. Election night count, unofficial.
Pompey town supervisor75 votes
2.2 pts
Cicero town supervisor (this race)297 votes
2.2 pts
Onondaga town supervisor1,135 votes
11.1 pts
Marcellus town supervisor364 votes
11.4 pts
Clay town supervisor2,838 votes
12.0 pts
Salina town supervisor1,694 votes
13.8 pts
Skaneateles town supervisor672 votes
17.5 pts
Spafford town supervisor162 votes
18.5 pts
Manlius town supervisor4,757 votes
30.0 pts
DeWitt town supervisor4,276 votes
45.9 pts
This raceOther races
Source: Onondaga County Board of Elections, unofficial election night results, 449 of 449 precincts, as of Nov. 4, 2026
Margins come from the county’s election night count. Absentee ballots that arrived after Election Day and affidavit ballots were counted later and can shift them slightly before certification.
Most of Cicero is in County Legislature District 3, where Republican Timothy T. Burtis won another term by 1,110 votes over Democrat Graeme Spicer. County Executive Ryan McMahon was not on the ballot, but voters approved a 12-year term limit for his office that will not count the years he has already served.
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT
The Board of Elections is counting the last absentee and affidavit ballots before it certifies the results in late November. Town officials elected to full terms on Nov. 3 take office on Jan. 1, 2027, and new town boards will hold organizational meetings early in the new year.
For results in every Onondaga County race, plus profiles of the officials who represent each city, town and village, visit PagPol’s Onondaga County page or subscribe to the Onondaga County newsletter. PagPol will update these numbers after the Board of Elections finishes counting late absentee and affidavit ballots and certifies the results.