Photo: Mr. Matté, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Democrat Justin K. Neal unseated Onondaga County Legislator Brian F. May on Nov. 3, winning District 1 by 6,443 votes to 6,214 in the county’s election night count. The 229-vote margin flipped a Republican seat in the county’s northwest corner, which takes in the town of Lysander and part of Van Buren.
Neal ran on the Democratic and Working Families lines, and May, the Republican incumbent, ran on the Republican and Conservative lines. District 1 was one of four Republican seats Democrats won on Nov. 3, a result that left Republicans with only three of the Legislature’s 17 seats heading into 2027.
Quick Facts
Office
Onondaga County Legislature, District 1
Area
Lysander and part of Van Buren
Winner
Justin K. Neal (Democratic, Working Families)
Runner-up
Brian F. May (Republican, Conservative)
Result
6,443 to 6,214 (50.9% to 49.1%)
Margin
229 votes
Status
Unofficial election night count, 449 of 449 precincts
THE RESULTS
Neal won 50.9 percent of the votes cast for candidates to 49.1 percent for May, a margin of 229 votes, in the Board of Elections’ unofficial results from all 449 precincts. Absentee ballots that arrived after Election Day and affidavit ballots were counted later and are not in these figures.
Justin K. Neal ✓(winner)Democratic, Working Families
6,443 (50.9%)
Brian F. MayRepublican, Conservative
6,214 (49.1%)
Write-ins
4
No vote in this race
241
DemocraticWorking FamiliesRepublicanConservativeWrite-ins and blanks
Source: Onondaga County Board of Elections, unofficial election night results, 449 of 449 precincts, as of Nov. 4, 2026
Justin K. Neal’s votes on the Democratic and Working Families lines against Brian F. May’s on the Republican and Conservative lines, with write-ins and blank ballots.
Neal drew 5,933 on the Democratic line and 510 on the Working Families line. May drew 5,351 on the Republican line and 863 on the Conservative line. Write-in votes totaled 4, and 241 ballots recorded no vote in the race, a PagPol calculation, since the county does not report blank ballots.
HOW THE VOTE BROKE DOWN
May’s loss came in a district where the party lines nearly balanced. Neal’s 5,933 Democratic votes beat May’s 5,351 Republican votes by 582, but May’s 863 Conservative votes put him ahead by 281. Neal’s 510 votes on the Working Families line then carried him past the incumbent by 229.
Democrats came into the election holding 10 of the Legislature’s 17 seats, including one member elected on the Working Families line. They flipped four Republican seats on Nov. 3, in Districts 1, 2, 11 and 14, which gives them 14 seats to the Republicans’ three once the new terms begin.
Legislator Brian F. May, the Republican who held District 1 (Photo: Onondaga County Legislature)
HOW IT COMPARES
Neal’s 1.8-point margin was the second-closest of the 17 Legislature races on election night. Only District 14 in eastern Clay, where Democrat Jessica Dapson led Republican Legislator Cody M. Kelly by 91 votes, was decided by a smaller share of the vote than District 1.
Winning margin in each Onondaga County Legislature race
Points between the winner and runner-up, share of votes cast for candidates. Election night count, unofficial.
Legislature District 1491 votes
0.8 pts
Legislature District 1 (this race)229 votes
1.8 pts
Legislature District 12377 votes
2.9 pts
Legislature District 6697 votes
4.8 pts
Legislature District 11709 votes
5.6 pts
Legislature District 13658 votes
5.6 pts
Legislature District 5825 votes
8.2 pts
Legislature District 31,110 votes
9.1 pts
Legislature District 41,857 votes
17.2 pts
Legislature District 21,821 votes
17.2 pts
Legislature District 102,357 votes
17.7 pts
Legislature District 73,746 votes
43.2 pts
Legislature District 92,026 votes
45.1 pts
Legislature District 83,799 votes
55.3 pts
Legislature District 174,779 votes
58.6 pts
Legislature District 161,997 votes
59.5 pts
Legislature District 154,868 votes
68.5 pts
This raceOther races
Source: Onondaga County Board of Elections, unofficial election night results, 449 of 449 precincts, as of Nov. 4, 2026
Margins come from the county’s election night count. Absentee ballots that arrived after Election Day and affidavit ballots were counted later and can shift them slightly before certification.
Lysander voters also chose a new town councilor on the same ballot, electing Democrat Timothy R. Osier over Republican Tony McIntyre by 481 votes to fill a vacancy. County Executive Ryan McMahon, a Republican, was not on the ballot this year, and his term runs through 2027.
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT
The Board of Elections is counting the last absentee and affidavit ballots before it certifies the results in late November. New legislature terms begin in January 2027, when the Legislature will also choose its leaders for the year.
For results in every Onondaga County race, plus profiles of the officials who represent each city, town and village, visit PagPol’s Onondaga County page or subscribe to the Onondaga County newsletter. PagPol will update these numbers after the Board of Elections finishes counting late absentee and affidavit ballots and certifies the results.